Job news & views

Search

Post your resume

Back

Print

Is recruitment consulting the most stressful job in the world?

7 August 2008

Sarah Butcher

According to a study by the unlikely combination of Siemens and The Stroke Association, people who work in recruitment are particularly stressed – more so than lawyers, teachers, marketing professionals and bankers.

The study doesn’t explain the precise source of recruiters’ angst but, according to the recruiters we spoke to, it’s partly attributable to the pay structure.

“This is a sales job,” says one. “You’re working on commission so it’s bound to be stressful.”

“It’s no more stressful than being a trader,” says the head of another recruitment firm dismissively. “There’s stress with any well-remunerated City job.”

Phillip Hodson, a counsellor known for his work with disconsolate white-collar workers, doesn’t have too many recruitment consultants on his books, but says some of his best friends are recruiters: “Recruitment isn’t like selling a joint of lamb or two pounds of apples – you have to manage people, who are inherently unpredictable. It can be very hard to meet someone’s expectations of the perfect job.”

But rather than recruitment consultants, Hodson says it’s bankers who are currently queuing up for psychological modification.

“The whole world of investment banking and financial services is an emotional mess,” he muses. “Enquiries from bankers are up around 10% on last year. People are increasingly exploring the notion of getting out of the industry, but if you’re a 40-year-old investment banker on a six-figure package, switching to become a primary school teacher on £26k a year is a hard move to make.”

Comments (45)

I was once a good looking, but fairly average headhunter, the constant pressure caused me all sorts of intestinal problems

View all comments

Bookmark

  • Digg.com
  • Del.icio.us
  • Stumbleupon.com
  • Reddit.com
  • Yahoo.com

Comments (45)

  • The key to success and weeding out the parasites is to work for a niche industry, market leader, who are small enough to keep it personal and big enough to have a real importance in the market they operate in. Our head office has 18 people in it and you can see who's crap and who's not - it's a very transparent environment... and YES... we can also see the difference we make in people's lives becauwse we work extremely closely with your candidates - it's a small market we operate in and EVERYONE knows EVERYONE! I have worked for both of the major players in 'mainstream' recruitment, one who I would term "the old boys network" and the other who is so heavily US regulated it makes it almost impossible to do your jobs properly for spreadsheets and reporting getting in the way....
    Keep things simple... work with candidates you truly believe you can help... don't lie... be honest... only promise on what you genuinely CAN do... simple simple simple...(God it sounds so cliched)

    I love my job... yes - it's diffciult and stressful at times but only cause I let it get to me... got to keep ahead of the game and work smart

    Sarah 14 Aug 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • I'm a recruiter, but I agree with everything Brent says.  The industry is clogged up with parasites who are kept in a job by incompetent and often corrupt HR professionals who make little effort to forge useful partnerships or weed out the bad eggs.

    The wide boys spouting their bitterness and insecurity make me ashamed to be part of their profession.

    Self Loathing 14 Aug 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • Recruitment is an astonishingly stressful job.The sheer unpredictability and constant changing managing of people means you can never leave it at work.  On top of that the hour by hour pressure to keep the volume up cvs, calls,interviews can be overwhelming

    And to top it all, have a couple of bad months and you could be out.

    Carl 13 Aug 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • I have been in recruitment for almost 30 years. The real stress comes when a recruiter runs his own business, not when s/he is employed someone else. This will be the third recruitment recession that I have worked through and it gets tougher every time, but that is because my monthly expenditure is higher by the time the next recession arrives. Those that are young, sub 30, really are not stressed, they have just had a really easy time of things so far.
    In the last 9 months I have personally had several candidates reject offers from clients, a sure sign of a recession when candidates would rather stay with the devil they know than be the last in first out victim.
    The recession is here for recruiters, especially in Banking, but that just means cut costs, reduce expenses, visiting more people, networking harder. The usual things, oh and don't tell the wife that the house is being used as security yet again.

    Gary Wilson 11 Aug 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • A personal question to recruiters.
    Where do they believe they add value?
    Coming from an environment of direct applications where you apply for the jobs you want, you present your CV the way you want, you schedule the interviews as you like it, you get your feedback directly and freely...

    Sorry , so far, recruiters:
    - Always put me in the box they believe I am going to pass and get their fee.
    - Chop my CV the way they like it.
    - Push the interviews in the way the client wants, not me.
    - Give the feedback they want.

    Justme 10 Aug 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • Not proud of people knocking re consultants but it just seems this has become a bit of a joke in terms of every week there is somebody knocking us down in an article so I do not think we should knock how our colleagues work. People work in a way that suits them.  Everyone is trying to do their best and earn a living. Live and let live.

    doug 08 Aug 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • Brent get on with your bl**dy work...if i catch you posting on this again im going straight to the boss

    dan 08 Aug 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • Sarah - I get your point and its only understandable for a recruiter to check EFC...Maybe you could enlighten me more over a drink or two!!

    Brent 08 Aug 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • Brent - the reason we are on here is because we regularly receive news updates from sites such as E-financial Careers on the industry, updates on what's new, etc. to keep abreast of what's going on out there. It just so happened, as I'm sure is the case for most of the contributors on this thread, that this topic was posted just the other day to which an email alert was sent out straight away... it's a topic of major interest... it gets responses... that's the way these things work... again... people in every industry will be doing the same! Not just recruiters... p.s. the only reason I am on here at 9.07 am is because I hadn't switched all of my programs off and this was still running so I was curious to see what the update was... before you say anything :)

    Sarah 08 Aug 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • Getting back to the topic at hand, recruitment consultants are the most stressful employees in the world.

    Is this due to the general quality of employees in banking, law and recruitment consultancy?  Look at the barriers to entry:

    Investment banking:
    2:1 (or better) degree in numerical subject from top 10 university, psychometric tests, many rounds in interviews

    Corporate law
    2:1 (or better) degree in Law from top 10 university, LPC, psychometric tests, many rounds of interviews

    Recruitment consultant
    GCSE Maths & English?

    Dave 07 Aug 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

Add your comment

* Mandatory

You have 1200 characters left

Enter the code shown here or sign in / register to skip this step. (What is this?)

Post comment

Col3
Col4
Col5
Col6
bottom

Site Information

eFinancialCareers is a Dice Holdings, Inc. company. Dice Holdings, Inc. is a publicly traded company listed on the New York Stock Exchange (Ticker: DHX)