Job news & views

Search

Post your resume

Back

Print

OUT OF LEHMAN: Headhunters have shut me out of the market

11 November 2008

There are two good reasons why people flock to business school – one, the network and two, because it opens doors. The career services team in b-school provides you with a great platform to interact with recruiters from different industries and ample opportunities to shift careers – you can walk in as Gordon Ramsay and graduate to become a Gordon Gekko. However, once you are out of business school and in the job market, that luxury doesn’t exist any more.

Let me explain. After graduating from b-school I joined Lehman in its capital markets division a couple of months back. My goal was to become a trader. I believe I have the right skill sets for it – I am humble, honest, willing to learn and pay my dues, have a good understanding of the markets and a deep interest in economics. But then, I picked the wrong firm, joined them in the wrong city, and chose the wrong division (fixed income). Four weeks ago, I was shown the door.

Ever since Lehman fired me, I have been looking for jobs. Naturally, nobody is interested in hiring me as a trader given that I have zilch experience and might not contribute a penny to the bottom line in the near future.

Fair enough: I switched angles, brought my accountant skills to the fore (I am a qualified chartered accountant) and pitched to become a research analyst. I can dissect financial statements when I am half asleep, have been personally invested in the markets for over eight years now, and used to make a living by researching and writing tax opinions for clients – enough to check all the right boxes? Hmm... maybe not. Yet again, quoting my lack of ‘relevant’ experience and the abundant supply of qualified labour in the market, I was shot down.

Given how the London job market works, ie, via headhunters, it makes it all the more difficult for people in my position to get into the market. When the MDs and VPs are there for the taking, why bother with a trivial first-year associate!

It took me two weeks and dozens more calls before a respectable big-firm headhunter even agreed to meet with me in person.

But now, after meeting with a dozen headhunters, I have again hit a road block. I am not crying or giving excuses, but to me it seems like their incentive system is inherently designed to work against someone in my position. They look at candidates/resumes that fit with their requirements, rather than try to help me find what I am looking for. They are quick to quote market conditions as the reason why I should get back to doing what I used to do before my MBA. Sorry, but my dreams are not up for sale this soon.

That is the primary difference between careers services in b-school and headhunters in the job market. Careers services work with you to find what you want. They give you the opportunity to meet with potential recruiters – a chance to interview, to get your foot in the door.

By comparison, headhunters get paid to come up with the best ‘fitting’ candidates. You may be able to charm a company into hiring you, but that’s no help if headhunters won’t put you in front of them in the first place.

Comments (56)

We had people coming to the floor (do not know how).. walking up to the receptionist asking to speak to CIO, head of, senior etc. with their CV in hand!! ""HERE LOOK!!""

View all comments

Bookmark

  • Digg.com
  • Del.icio.us
  • Stumbleupon.com
  • Reddit.com
  • Yahoo.com

Comments (56)

  • "my dreams are not up for sale this soon."

    Dude, you gave up trying to be a trader, your supposed "dream" and tried to switch into research. What you are really saying is your "dream" is to make a lot of money in the City, doesn't matter how. You say you are honest but quite frankly, I don't see it. We are in a bear market, everybody is suffering and you keep dreaming of the past.

    American 11 Nov 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • Why are you blaming the 'headhunter' ,  I think you need to grow up abit and listen to yourself.  This is the up's and down's of life.. just get on with it and stop moaning.

    richardbray 11 Nov 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • Seems only natural given that the career services are funded by the bschool that you pay your fees for, while the headhunters are paid by the potential employer. Good lock with your job search though.

    M&AturnedPE 11 Nov 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • You have to be your own headhunter. At 4 weeks out of work you are GREEN. When you reach a year then see what your resolve is like.

    If you sit around waiting for a headhunter to call...your kids will have a better shot than you.

    Drifter 11 Nov 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • Whinge. Moan. Like you are the only one suffering.....

    Moan 11 Nov 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • Hey wake up my friend
    they are paid by firms. Not by you. Why should they bother to propose your CV while the market is full of people who have already direct experience in the job.
    They are here to help first themselves. then the company. Last in their ranking is you.
    tough world but put yourself in their shoes and you will do the same...
    I come from Lehman. myself (but was lucky yo move to Asia 1 year ago).
    If I can give you an advice my friend do not stay out of the game. Pick a job. Even not the right one. Even not the one you wanted. Because wait a few month out of the market and then you won't find anything...
    their was a good article on this website from a headhunter for LB employes. And the message was clear : real losers will be the one that stay out of the game for too long. Others will eventually catch up even if starting from lower.
    Just my 2 cents.
    Good luck to you anyway.

    SherKaan 11 Nov 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 1 time | Alert Moderator

  • My headhunter did help me. She rejected me and told me I should stop trying headhunters and wasting time. Headhunters help employers instead of candidates. Then she suggested I should try networking and internal referral.

    danny 11 Nov 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • What you have to ask yourself is why would any Bank/Fund ask a recruiter for a first year MBA associate?  If they want an associate then they want one who has done the three years of hard grind as an analyst and therefore doesn't require any training.
    You can't expect a headhunter to crowbar your into a job that you don't fit, otherwise we would just be slinging CVs across the city for jobs that didn't exist and we would take even more stick for that!  Use your contacts, those you met at B-School and those you worked for Lehman.  That's your best bet with the market like this.

    Good Luck

    reputable recruiter 11 Nov 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • Why do you insist on using b-school? This isn't text messaging you know. Unless of course it was b for class b school.

    And I admire your honesty. I really do. Not everyone is brilliant at looking at financial statements in their sleep. Is this supposed to be ironic? Perhaps you should try journalism?

    KK 11 Nov 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

  • Whiny culture of entitlement tosh from a classic end-of-the-bull market hire.  You think you've got the right skills to be a trader when you lack the chutzpah to approach potential employers direct?  When your tiny mind can't fathom the difference between the junior hires banks make from direct applicants - or don't make at all in this market - versus the senior specialist roles for which they retain a headhunter, and for which you are patently underqualified?  When you don't recognize the contrast between campus careers advisory 'yes men' and the commercial cut and thrust of London headhunters?  Pitiful.

    A reader 11 Nov 2008

    RECOMMEND Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator

Add your comment

* Mandatory

You have 1200 characters left

Enter the code shown here or sign in / register to skip this step. (What is this?)

Post comment

Jobs

Col3
Col4
Col5
Col6
bottom

Site Information

eFinancialCareers is a Dice Holdings, Inc. company. Dice Holdings, Inc. is a publicly traded company listed on the New York Stock Exchange (Ticker: DHX)